3 Comments
User's avatar
Glaister Prince's avatar

Great insight EM

The current dust up in the BITCOIN community epitomizes the struggle between the “experts “ the coders and the “generalists “ who yearn for a system where exploitation is not incentivized. We are at a crossroads the continuation of the age old system where net worth is the end game or to a system where networks will be more important and fulfilling.

GG's avatar

A step towards fostering understanding - and respect - among disciplines: levels of analysis. Example: human behavior and how to explain it. Biochemical: the biologist. Go up a level to a systems level: the physician. Go up a level to studying 'mind' - the psychologist. Study people in communities: the sociologist. Go up again to multi-cultural: the anthropologist. Go up again to totality, or down to ultimate first principles: the philosopher, or priest.

All are true - or false depending on what the consumer of the information provided by each deems relevant, or 'true.' In the siloed society, everything other than my favorite and habitual level of analysis is designated as crap. Or 'conspiracy theory......"

GG's avatar

Notice health care. A dozen specialists, a dozen opinions and medications. Who co-ordinates overall care pattern? Sadly, no-one (speaking from personal and professional experience). The general practitioner is best-placed to do so because he also knows the patient best, but because he is but a 'lowly generalist' he cannot countermand the specialists. Ergo, drugs that are contra-indicated in combination get pushed onto a patient to sometimes deadly effects.

Ditto the pharmacists BTW; if they - like the GP - have the courage to bring this to the attention of the specialists something might get done, but few do. Software is available to prevent such things - as is human experience, but.....

And even with the knowledge with the current ethos, frequently specialists don't even bother to return calls to patients, or other doctors, which makes one wonder: "How can this be?"

Tangential point shifting perspectives: part of what at a deep level makes many if not most cubicle people feel anxious and depressed is the utter lack of variety in life itself. Unidimensional widgetry sucks the soul unto death.